In 2019, USDA moved offices for the Economic Research Service (ERS) and National Institute of Food and Agriculture (NIFA) from Washington D.C. to Kansas City, MO. A new report by the Government Accountability Office (GAO) found the relocation overlooked key evidence and did not follow an evidence-based approach.
In an April 21 report, GAO detailed that USDA’s economic analysis did not fully align with its objectives to attract staff, be closer to stakeholders and reduce taxpayer costs. The agency gave the example of USDA using cost of living to screen locations and then eliminating locations that could not house both ERS and NIFA. GAO noted some of the locations actually ranked highly in terms of USDA’s stakeholder proximity and staff recruitment and retention objectives.
In addition, the department omitted critical costs and economic effects from its analysis of taxpayer savings, the report said. This included costs related to “potential attrition or disruption of activities for a period of time,” which could have contributed to an unreliable estimate of savings from relocation.
GAO overall found USDA’s development and usage of evidence had significant limitations, and key characteristics of a high-quality analysis were absent, including transparency efforts.
“As a result of the weaknesses GAO found, USDA leadership may have made a relocation decision that was not the best choice to accomplish its stated objectives,” the report read.
GAO reviewed USDA’s contracting documents and contractor deliverables, interviewed USDA officials and contractor staff, and evaluated the economic analysis using criteria included in GAO’s assessment methodology for economic analysis.
The office said it is not making any recommendations at this time because the relocation has already taken place, and the Office of Management and Budget has since released guidance on how to build and use quality evidence that should address highlighted weaknesses.
“USDA neither agreed nor disagreed with our findings but disagreed with the criteria we used to evaluate the agency’s economic analysis. We stand by our analysis as discussed in the report,” GAO concluded.
Background
In June of 2019, then-Secretary of Agriculture Sonny Perdue announced the USDA would be relocating the ERS and NIFA to Kansas City. He said the decision was based on retaining staff, moving USDA resources closer to agriculture areas and benefitting taxpayers.
The move had the opposite effect for retaining staff, as about 65-75 percent of employees chose to not relocate and instead left the agencies. The agencies have struggled to replace and retain staff since then, and they are operating with about 30 percent fewer employees today than they were before the relocation.
A USDA cost-benefit analysis produced before the move claimed relocating to Kansas City would save $300 million during a 15-year lease term on employment costs and rent, or about $20 million per year. USDA received about $26 million in incentives.
Critics said the move was an attempt to downsize the agencies, while supporters argued the move would be economically beneficial and increase proximity to other ag businesses. — Anna Miller, WLJ managing editor
