When pandemic-induced closures at several large slaughter plants disrupted the supply chain last spring, panicked consumers began seeking alternate ways to fill their freezers. Small slaughter plants and meat lockers across the nation suddenly found themselves inundated, not only with new customers, but also with a flood of custom slaughter clients looking to tap the burgeoning market. While the wider meat supply chain has largely righted itself, the increased demand at local slaughter facilities, so far, has not abated.
[inline_image file=”ec68eb7d4f770c2ed4de28daa74b25c0.jpg” caption=”Consumer habits are shifting as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. Photo courtesy of Beef It’s What’s For Dinner.”]
Business is booming
“It’s been insane,” says Sam Hunt, owner of C&L Locker in Moscow, ID. “Typically, in this area, things get slower in February and March. But when COVID hit, things went through the roof.” A long-time meat retailer in the Moscow area, Hunt recently purchased a neighboring facility outside of town. Lacking a true retail space at his new facility, Hunt was forced to think creatively in order to meet the increasing demand.
“We started a program called a weekly bundle,” he explains. “For $50, we guarantee around 10 pounds of meat. It’s geared towards giving a family of two meat for dinner every night. “The packages are a surprise,” he adds. “You give us $50 by Wednesday afternoon, and on Friday you come pick up your brown bag that will have about 10 pounds of meat in it. It might be chicken, pork, beef, smoked sausages, bacon, whatever I can drum up to throw in there and hit that $50 value.”
According to Hunt, this marketing model has proven extremely popular as consumers in the region increasingly look to shop local and avoid large retailers. “The only complaint I’ve had is that it’s too much meat for one week,” he says. He indicates that some customers have actually dropped off his weekly list, simply because they have no more freezer space. “I don’t look at that as a lost sale,” he says. “I look at it as doing my part, providing good value for their money.”
In addition to retail sales, C&L also does custom slaughtering, and has seen dramatic increases in that side of the business as well, as grassfed and other direct-to-consumer producers seek to expand their own businesses. “Everyone that I normally butcher for has doubled their numbers, and some have scheduled me three years out,” says Hunt. “I think I have a few spots available in June or July of next year, but that’s about it.”
With his grassfed clients in particular, Hunt says that he has worked with those producers to alter their traditional slaughter dates, not only to meet his slaughter capabilities, but also to improve their end products. “Historically, my grassfed customers have always wanted to butcher in October and November,” he says. “I’ve had to tell them that I can’t, I’m already full in that time period.”
[inline_image file=”29b45d01269d91c5386ff50a9c851795.jpg” caption=”U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) meat inspectors and graders perform their mission. USDA photo by Preston Keres”]
Additionally, Hunt indicated that waiting until the fall, long after the peak grass season has passed, results in calves that are losing condition by the time he gets them. “Many producers think that their calves are going to continue to gain, even as grass quality declines,” he says. “That isn’t what happens. If you’re trying to do these yearlings into a grassfed market in this area, the best time to kill is in July. They’ll be in the best condition and you’ll have the best quality you’re going to get.”
If you can’t find one, buy one
There can be little doubt, grassfed and other direct-to-consumer marketers are a significant driver of the surge in business for small slaughterhouses and packers around the country. Even prior to COVID, however, slaughter capacity has been a major pinch point for these producers. This is primarily due to an ever-shrinking number of available slaughter facilities.
According to USDA statistics, in 1998, there were slightly over 12,000 small or very small slaughter plants operating in the U.S. (USDA classifies any slaughter plant with less then 500 employees in one of these two categories). By 2018, just 4,000 remained. While many of the remaining plants have seen increased business in recent years, much of it is due to an ever-increasing lack of competition.
One side effect of this attrition, however, is a landscape dotted with shuttered slaughterhouses. With the pandemic increasing the potential profit margins of these businesses, ranchers in several regions have begun acquiring these derelict facilities, with an eye towards putting them back into production.
For grassfed producer and newly-minted slaughterhouse owner Allyn Fuchs, the decision to acquire a plant stemmed from quality and scheduling problems that began well before the pandemic. Based in Santa Rosa, NM, Fuchs has been direct marketing grassfed beef for eight years.
In 2019, however, with the popularity of that business model on the rise, Fuchs found himself increasingly jostled when it came to scheduling slaughter dates at his nearest USDA-inspected facility. “Twice I showed up with cattle and they sent me home, because they had forgotten to write down the appointment,” he says. “Three more times I called ahead, because it’s an hour drive, and they still sent me home loaded.”
Frustrated, Fuchs began using a slaughter facility in neighboring Texas, only to find that they were confusing his animals in the cutting room. “If I run old grinder cows through along with finished calves, I can’t have them getting mixed up,” he explains. “I don’t personally try every beef I get back, and it’s a problem to have the wrong stuff going out to customers. I don’t like other people trying to put me out of business.”
[inline_image file=”052bcd58ca99bc9cd0a69eaa30b0d316.jpg” caption=”Beef hanging on an inspection line. Photo by USDA.”]
Eventually, the Texas plant also began cutting Fuchs back on the number of animals they could slaughter for him. When the pandemic struck, and demand for Fuch’s beef more than tripled, he found himself at an impasse. Although he had the cattle, he couldn’t meet demand because he had no way to slaughter it.
In mid-2020, when a chance meeting with another producer informed him that a slaughter plant in nearby Mountainair, NM, was closing its doors, Fuchs says he didn’t hesitate.
“I got on the phone with the people that owned it right away,” he says. “I leased the plant, bought the business that was operating there, and our first day operating was Nov. 2.” Beginning with custom slaughter projects, Monte Alto Artisan Meats, with Fuchs and his business partner at the helm, processed its first inspected carcasses for retail sale on Nov. 23. “I figure if you’re going to do something like this, you’ve got to swing for the fences,” says Fuchs.
Challenges
While the potential for profit is there, restarting a slaughter facility is anything but a simple proposition. In many cases federal certifications have lapsed, requiring a lengthy process to regain. These facilities are also often outdated, potentially requiring massive investments to meet requirements and be functional at a competitive level. Even Fuchs, who was fortunate enough to secure a plant that was already operating and inspected, has had to overcome facility issues.
“This place was actually built as a sheep plant,” he says. “So we have to quarter everything, because there’s no place to hang a full carcass.” To circumvent this issue, Fuchs has taken a modular approach, adding specially fitted semi-trailers to augment his floor space.
“The week before I got this plant, I bought a 48-foot refrigerated trailer with rails in it,” he says. “Since then we’ve bought another freezer trailer to store finished product. That has basically quadrupled the capacity of this plant.”
As with their larger counterparts, skilled labor is another area where smaller plants typically struggle. Labor issues have long plagued the slaughter industry as a whole. The work is both physically and mentally demanding, and it is difficult to find the right people for the job. Fuchs currently employs seven full-time workers, and is on the hunt for more. “I’ve learned you don’t sleep much when you own a processing plant,” he says. “I worked 96 hours last week, and 110 the week before that.”
Even long-time operators, like Hunt, find themselves perennially faced with labor shortages. “I get people who come in and want to learn how to do it, but can’t hack it,” he says. “It’s hard work, and I can’t hire somebody at $30 an hour to learn.”
Located near a university, Hunt admits that he does have access to a ready supply of unskilled labor, but points out that this leads to a constant revolving door of employees, many of whom fundamentally lack enthusiasm for the work. “I can get people to come to work, but their output or their motivation is not as intense as mine is,” he says. “I feel the pressure, my long-time workers feel the pressure, my wife feels the pressure, but everyone else is going home at 5 p.m.”
“They say plants are going to be cheap in a few years because all these people are going to open them and then go out of business. But at the same time they are saying that they are booked out for a year into the future.”
Hunt has even tried sweetening the pot, offering increasingly generous compensation packages, all to no avail. “I’ve offered someone with eight years of experience $20 per hour, paid vacation, insurance, and an equity option on the business after three years,” he says. “He said he’d keep it in mind.”
Looking forward
While experts agree that the current trend for small processing facilities is likely to continue as long as the pandemic does, what will happen if and when things return to normal is uncertain. “All the processors I talk to say this thing will thin out and that it won’t be that big a deal next year,” says Fuchs.
“They say plants are going to be cheap in a few years because all these people are going to open them and then go out of business. “But at the same time, they are saying that they are booked out for a year into the future,” he adds.
While Hunt anticipates a slowdown once the pandemic panic subsides, he also believes that enough new customers will remain to sustain his business well into the future. “Once this is all over, some people will go back to their old habits, but many of them will have created new ones,” he says.
“In some ways, they’re doing what their grandparents did 50 years ago, buying in bulk and eating at home more. I think that may be a trend for at least the next 15-20 years.”
“Everyone who ran out and bought freezers is going to want to keep something in them. A lot of people have had to learn to save money and cook for themselves,” he adds. “In some ways, they’re doing what their grandparents did 50 years ago, buying in bulk and eating at home more. I think that may be a trend for at least the next 15-20 years.”
One thing is certain: For as long as the current trend does last, small processors like Fuchs and Hunt intend to ride the wave. “I’m trying to take advantage of this while it’s here,” says Hunt. “This will cycle, and it can be a difficult industry.”
