Advertisement
Opinion

Compass Comments: Psychology of price

Compass Ag Solutions
Nov. 20, 2026 6 minutes read
Compass Comments: Psychology of price

Cole Rogers, Compass Ag Solutions business and risk management consultant, may be reached at 970-212-0961 or coler@compassagsolutions.com.

In commodity markets, almost every producer is a price taker in the traditional sense. Nobody at the sale barn gets to name their own price. But there’s another way to think about it. For this article, a price taker is someone who waits and accepts whatever the market offers on sale day. A price maker is someone who makes an active risk management decision ahead of sale day, choosing a price level or a floor they can live with instead of leaving the outcome entirely to chance.

Both are choices. Waiting is a decision just as much as pricing is, it simply doesn’t always feel like one.

Being a price taker transfers responsibility to the market. If the cattle market falls and you never managed price risk, it’s easy to say, “That’s how it goes sometimes.” But if you establish a price and the market subsequently rallies, the result can feel much more personal: “I made the wrong decision.”

That reaction reflects two well-documented biases: regret aversion and omission bias. Together, they describe our tendency to evaluate negative outcomes more harshly when they result from an active decision than when they result from doing nothing. It is often easier to be disappointed by the market than disappointed in our own decision.

Active approaches create accountability. When a decision costs money, it can be difficult to recognize the value of that decision if it’s not measured in dollars. If you buy Livestock Risk Protection and prices never fall enough to trigger an indemnity, the premium can feel like “money spent” rather than “protection purchased.” Yet nobody calls a fire insurance premium wasted because the barn didn’t burn. Protection can have value even when it’s not used.

We tend to evaluate risk management by outcomes rather than by the quality of the decision when it was made. Too often, a hedge, floor or forward contract is judged afterward as though it were a speculative bet. If the market rallies above the protected price, the difference can emotionally register as a loss, even if the cattle remain profitable. But the purpose of managing price risk isn’t to predict the market high. It is to help protect the operation from an unacceptable outcome.

That becomes especially powerful in a rising market. Recency bias causes our expectations to rise along with prices. What looked like an exceptional price six months ago can suddenly feel disappointing. We may begin anchoring our expectations to the highest price we’ve seen, last year’s check or what a neighbor received. A price below that reference point can feel like a loss even when it remains profitable.

Waiting for that price preserves hope, but hope isn’t free. The cost is uncertainty and continued exposure to a market decline.

Long-term success is less about calling market highs and more about protecting the financial foundation that allows an operation to endure difficult markets, take advantage of future opportunities, and pass to the next generation. In my opinion, that is the most important goal.

Is being a price taker an intentional strategy? There is nothing inherently wrong with choosing to be a price taker. The more important question is whether that choice is intentional.

Have you considered the opportunity cost of waiting? Have you evaluated the alternatives and determined that accepting whatever price the market provides on sale day gives your operation the best opportunity for success?

There isn’t one right answer for every operation. The point is not that every producer should manage price risk the same way. The point is that carrying price risk should be a conscious business decision rather than simply the absence of a decision.

Make the decision before the emotion. Recognizing these biases is one thing. Managing around them requires discipline. One way to do that is to establish your parameters before market movements begin influencing your expectations. Ask yourself: What price provides an acceptable return for my operation? At what price would a decline begin creating financial stress? What am I willing to spend (or give up) to protect the space between the two?

Markets will change, but having a framework established beforehand can help keep emotion from continually moving the goalposts. Having the discipline to follow a plan is often harder than putting risk management itself in place.

Most importantly, grade the decision, not the outcome. Instead of asking, “Did I receive the highest price?” or “Did my risk management make money?” ask, “Was this a sound decision based on what I knew and what my operation needed at the time?”

Sometimes a good risk management decision will look unnecessary in hindsight. Other times, doing nothing will work out perfectly. Neither outcome, by itself, tells you whether the original decision was sound.

Learning to say, “I made the best decision I could with the information I had,” may be one of the most important disciplines in managing price risk. — COLE ROGERS

(Cole Rogers is a business and risk management consultant at Compass Ag Solutions.)

(This material should be construed as the solicitation of an account, order, and/or services provided by Compass Hedging LLC [NFA ID: 0442312] and represents the opinions and viewpoints of the author. It does not constitute an individualized recommendation or take into account the particular trading objectives, financial situations, or needs of individual customers. Additionally, this material should not be construed as research material. The trading of derivatives such as futures and futures options may not be suitable for all investors. Derivatives trading involves substantial risk of loss, and you should fully understand the risks prior to trading. Past results are not necessarily indicative of future results. Compass Hedging LLC is not responsible for any redistribution of this material by third parties, or any trading decisions taken by persons not intended to view this material. Information contained herein was obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but its accuracy, timeliness, and/or completeness cannot be guaranteed. Compass Ag Insurance is an equal opportunity provider.)

Share this article

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Keep reading

Related stories

From the byline

More from Compass Ag Solutions

View all by Compass Ag Solutions

E-Edition

This week’s WLJ

Latest issue

November 16, 2026

New this week

Read the current National Livestock Weekly online, or browse the full newspaper archive.

Print subscription

Get WLJ delivered every week

Markets, ranch news, and sale reports—in print and online for members.