A federal appeals court ruled that key parts of Idaho’s stockwater laws violate the U.S. Constitution by targeting federal water rights tied to public lands grazing.
The decision by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals involved Idaho laws adopted after the Snake River Basin Adjudication (SRBA), which confirmed thousands of federal stockwater rights. The three-judge panel found the state’s stockwater amendments were designed, in part, to divest the federal government of those previously established rights.
Writing for the court, U.S. Circuit Judge Jennifer Sung said the provisions violated the Constitution’s Supremacy Clause, which generally prevents states from directly regulating or discriminating against the federal government.
Stockwater rights challenged
The dispute grew out of the decades-long SRBA, which adjudicated hundreds of thousands of water rights across the Snake River Basin. A final decree issued in 2014 confirmed thousands of stockwater rights the federal government claimed under Idaho’s constitutional method of appropriation.
Idaho later adopted a series of laws known as the stockwater amendments. The federal government challenged several provisions, arguing they could be used to take away water rights already confirmed through adjudication.
One provision, Idaho Code § 42-224, created a process for determining whether stockwater rights have been forfeited after five years without beneficial use. A petition can be filed with the Idaho Department of Water Resources (IDWR), which can then begin a process requiring the water-right holder to show why the right has not been forfeited. A forfeiture dispute can ultimately move into state district court.
Although much of the forfeiture process appears to apply broadly to stockwater-right holders, the 9th Circuit looked at the law alongside the other stockwater amendments and the Idaho Legislature’s stated purpose for adopting them. Idaho argued the law simply created a process for enforcing longstanding forfeiture standards and did not prevent the federal government from defending its water rights.
Sung disagreed, writing that the argument “rings hollow” because the broader amendments reflect the state’s position that grazing permittees cannot be considered agents of the federal government without certain agreements.
Even if those agreements are not required for the federal government to retain its rights, Sung wrote, the process still forces the U.S. to defend against “burdensome collateral attacks” on rights already established through the SRBA.
The panel concluded the provision discriminates against the federal government and is unconstitutional as applied to the U.S.
Grazing permit transfers
The 9th Circuit also affirmed a lower court ruling that Idaho Code § 42-113(2)(b), which deals with grazing permits and associated stockwater rights, is unconstitutional.
Under Idaho’s general rule, water rights acquired through beneficial use are attached to the land where the water is used. The stockwater amendment created a different system when those rights are associated with grazing on federally owned or managed land.
In those cases, the water right would instead be tied to the grazing permittee’s private base property. When a federal grazing permit is transferred to a new owner, the associated stockwater rights could also transfer and attach to the new permit holder’s property.
The court found that arrangement could effectively separate stockwater rights from the federal land where the water is used.
Because the provision applies specifically to stockwater rights associated with federally owned or managed land, the panel found it unlawfully discriminates against the U.S. and affirmed the lower court’s finding that it violates the Supremacy Clause.
Idaho family fights curtailment
The decision comes as another water-rights dispute involving IDWR is playing out in state court.
Jerry and Valerie Bingham filed a lawsuit Sept. 21 against Idaho and IDWR in the District Court of the State of Idaho, 7th Judicial District, Bingham County. The family alleges the state effectively took its water rights without paying just compensation.
The Binghams farm about 1,000 acres in Bingham County, where three generations of the family have farmed. Most of their groundwater rights date to the early 1950s and rank among the most senior in the Eastern Snake River Plain aquifer.
According to the complaint, IDWR’s July 2025 curtailment order and later orders have kept the Binghams from pumping groundwater for most of the past year, except for a brief period in spring 2026. The family argues the state curtailed their senior water rights while allowing some junior water users under approved mitigation plans to keep pumping.
The family says losing access to irrigation water threatens the farm’s future. The complaint estimates about $300,000 in lost revenue from potato production in 2025 and 2026 and about $388,000 in lost revenue from reduced wheat production in 2026.
“The case is about more than one family’s farm,” said Damien Schiff, senior attorney at Pacific Legal Foundation representing the Binghams. “It asks whether the institutions governing scarce resources will give people the certainty to invest, steward those resources responsibly, and produce an abundant future, or whether arbitrary decisions will make all three harder.”
The Binghams are asking the court to find that the state took their property without just compensation and to award compensation, interest, attorney fees and costs. — Charles Wallace, WLJ contributing editor

1 Comment